What does a contract have to say on the day things go wrong? People draft for the day everything goes right: the project ships, the invoice clears, the renewal gets signed. The pages that earn their keep are the ones nobody reads until a payment is late or a deliverable is missing.
I advise founders in California and New York, and the contracts that cost clients real money are the ones with a missing clause. A bad clause at least gets negotiated.
Who signs, and what has to be in writing
Start with the signature block, because it decides whether the document can be used against the person you care about. New York’s General Obligations Law section 5-701 makes certain agreements void unless they are in a writing signed by the party to be charged. That includes a deal whose own terms put performance past its first year, and a special promise to answer for another person’s debt. California’s Civil Code section 1624 has a similar list, with its own additions such as a lease longer than one year and an agreement employing a real estate broker for over a year, and a signed memorandum from the person being held to the deal, or from an agent, satisfies it.
Whoever drafts in New York is deciding what to include in a New York business contract, and the first two decisions are the identity of the parties and the signatures. Name each party as it appears on its registration. Put the signer’s title under the signature. If one side signs and the other does not, you have a document that binds only one of them.
Nine terms that should be on the page
Business contracts share a core, and the fastest way to review one is to check it against a list.
- The parties, named as registered, with the signer’s title
- What each side will deliver, described precisely enough that a stranger could tell whether it happened
- The price and the dates it is due
- The start date and the term, including how renewal works
- How either side can end the deal, and the notice required
- A fee clause that says who pays legal costs if there is a dispute
- A clause that deals with consequential damages and lost profits
- The law that governs and the place where disputes will be heard
- A signature and a date for each party
None of those lines is exotic. The skill is in the precision, and the precision is cheap to add while both sides still like each other. A scope described as “support as needed” will mean one thing to the person who is paid and something else to the person who pays.
Term and renewal deserve their own sentence because of the one-year rule. Picture a two-year agency engagement agreed over a call and confirmed with a thumbs-up emoji. Both New York and California treat a deal that stretches performance beyond twelve months from signing as one that needs a signed writing. Write the term down, and have the person you may need to hold to it sign. A renewal clause that rolls forward automatically needs the same attention: say how long each renewal lasts and how much notice stops it. If the renewal term itself would run past a year, the same signature rule applies to it, so the renewal mechanics belong in the signed document and not in a follow-up email thread. Calendar the notice date the day the contract is signed, because a clause that renews silently is only as good as the person who remembers to read it.
Termination language gets less care than it should. The useful version names the events that let a party leave (missed payment, a deliverable not accepted, insolvency) and says how notice is delivered. Without that, the argument is about whether a Slack message counted.
The fee clause decides who pays for the lawsuit
In New York, each side bears its own legal fees unless a statute, a court rule or the contract says otherwise. That is the American rule. A contractual indemnity clause covers fees in a suit between the two contracting parties only if that intent is “unmistakably clear,” under Hooper Associates v. AGS Computers (N.Y. Court of Appeals, 1989). The Court of Appeals reaffirmed the point in Sage Systems v. Liss in 2022.
A form indemnity clause that mentions “attorneys’ fees arising from claims” can therefore leave a contracting party without any fee recovery against the other side. If you want the winner to recover fees, write that sentence directly: the prevailing party in a dispute between the parties recovers its reasonable legal fees. Ambiguity costs money here, and nobody notices until the invoice from litigation counsel arrives. The sentence belongs in the contract at signing, in the same section as the payment terms, where the finance team will find it when a dispute starts. A negotiation about fees after a dispute starts is a negotiation between two people who no longer trust each other.
It also cuts both ways. A one-sided fee clause that favours you today can be read against you tomorrow, so decide whether the clause should protect whichever side wins, and draft it that way.
Damages you cannot assume you will recover
A contract is also a forecast of the money at stake if it fails, and New York law limits what a business can claim. General damages are those that are the natural and probable consequence of the breach. Consequential damages are recoverable only on a showing that they were foreseeable and within the contemplation of the parties when the contract was made, under Kenford Co. v. County of Erie (N.Y. Court of Appeals, 1989).
The earlier Kenford decision (1986) dealt with lost profits. Profits a new venture expected to make must be proven with reasonable certainty, and liability for them must have been within the parties’ contemplation at contracting. Kenford’s claimed profits were too speculative. The Appellate Division has kept applying Kenford, including in 2014 decisions, so I treat it as live law.
Punitive damages are the narrowest category. Rocanova v. Equitable Life Assurance Society (N.Y. Court of Appeals, 1994) allows them for breach of contract only when three things line up: the conduct would be a tort on its own, it is sufficiently egregious, and it targets the plaintiff while forming part of a wider pattern aimed at the public. A late shipment, standing alone, is a breach and is not an independent tort.
What belongs in the contract follows from that: if a loss would hurt your business, say in the agreement that both sides expect it. A supplier who knows a delayed component idles your production line has contemplated that loss. A supplier who was told only that a part was needed has not.
The same clause runs in the other direction. If you are the vendor, a sentence that excludes consequential damages and lost profits, or caps them, belongs in your draft before the customer’s lawyer proposes the opposite. Whichever side you sit on, decide the point on purpose and put it in a clause with its own heading, because a court reading an unclear paragraph will go back to the foreseeability test and ignore what you meant.
The time limit sits inside the deal
Every contract carries a limitation period whether or not the document mentions it. In New York, CPLR section 213(2) sets a six-year period for contract claims, express or implied, subject to exceptions elsewhere in the CPLR. In California, Code of Civil Procedure section 337(a) gives four years on a contract founded on a written instrument, and section 339(1) gives two years where it is not.
A company that contracts in both states is operating on two calendars. When a deal is governed by New York law, the six-year clock applies to oral and written agreements alike. In California, the two-year limit for oral agreements and the four-year limit for written ones mean the signed contract buys two extra years in which to sue.
Read it the way the other side’s lawyer will
The last pass is the one that gets skipped. Before signing, read your own contract from the position of the person who will argue against it. Where does it say who pays, when, and what happens if they do not? Which clause would you point to if an invoice went unpaid, and does it say what the other side owes you in that case? Does the termination clause match the renewal clause? If the signatory changed jobs, does the agreement still point to a real person?
Run that pass against a short list of what business owners should check before signing: the names, the scope, the money, the exit, the fee clause and the damages language. This is general information, so take your own counsel on the facts of your deal.
So what belongs in a contract before anyone signs? Whatever the person reading it on the worst day will need: the names, the work, the money, the exit, and the fee clause.

